Executive summary: A recently retired executive converted a concentrated $600,000 employer-stock position in his 401(k) to a taxable holding using Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA), rolled the non‑stock portion to an IRA, executed staged Roth conversions, and delayed Social Security. By doing so he shifted most future taxation to long‑term capital gains, reduced the IRA balance subject to required minimum distributions (RMDs), and improved after‑tax cash flow in his 70s and 80s.

Background: the client and the position

“John,” age 66 at separation in early 2026, spent 30 years at a publicly traded manufacturing company. His plan balances at separation:

  • 401(k): $930,000 total — $600,000 in company stock (cost basis $60,000) and $330,000 in diversified mutual funds
  • Pension: $18,000/year (single‑life annuity)
  • Projected Social Security at full retirement age: $20,500/year; he planned to delay to age 70
  • Filing status: married filing jointly; no other significant taxable accounts

John’s priorities: maximize after‑tax retirement cash flow in later decades, minimize tax‑driven volatility when RMDs begin, and preserve a legacy. He wanted to avoid a single large ordinary‑income tax event on his whole 401(k) and preferred capital‑gains treatment where possible.

Challenge

John faced three linked problems:

  • A concentrated, highly appreciated employer stock position inside a tax‑deferred 401(k) that, if rolled directly to an IRA, would make all future distributions ordinary income.
  • Anticipated RMDs (age 73 under current law) that could create higher marginal tax rates late in life if the traditional IRA balance remained large.
  • Need for cash flow to pay the ordinary tax on stock cost basis in the distribution year without undermining the broader plan.

Solution

John and his advisers implemented a multipart plan in the 12 months after separation:

  1. Elect an eligible lump‑sum distribution and take the company stock out of the 401(k) under the NUA rule (Internal Revenue Code Sec. 402(e)(4)). He paid ordinary income tax only on the stock’s cost basis ($60,000) in the distribution year.
  2. Roll the non‑stock portion ($330,000) directly into a traditional IRA to preserve tax deferral for those dollars.
  3. Perform staged Roth conversions from the traditional IRA — $50,000 per year — in low‑income years (2026–2028) to reduce the taxable traditional IRA balance before RMDs at age 73.
  4. Delay claiming Social Security until 70 to maximize the guaranteed benefit and create low‑tax windows for conversions.
  5. Sell company stock gradually from the taxable account (after satisfying the one‑time NUA election), realizing long‑term capital gains on the NUA portion when sold.

Why NUA?

NUA lets the appreciation in employer securities distributed from a qualified plan be taxed later at long‑term capital gains rates when those shares are sold. The stock’s cost basis is taxed as ordinary income in the distribution year; the appreciation (NUA) is not taxed until sale and then at LTCG rates. That split can be substantial when appreciation is large relative to basis — as in John’s case where $540,000 of the $600,000 position was NUA.

Implementation (timeline and steps)

Key operational steps and timing John’s team followed in 2026:

  1. Confirm plan eligibility for NUA. Before electing a lump‑sum, the adviser reviewed the plan’s summary plan description, confirmed the participant’s separation‑from‑service date, and obtained written confirmation from the plan administrator that a lump‑sum distribution with NUA treatment was permitted.
  2. Secure liquidity to pay ordinary tax on basis. John earmarked $20,000 of savings and planned a short‑term sale of a small mutual‑fund tranche to cover the estimated federal and state ordinary tax on the $60,000 basis to avoid selling NUA shares immediately.
  3. Execute the distribution and rollover. The administrator transferred the non‑stock balance directly to a traditional IRA trustee-to-trustee rollover while issuing the company stock as an in‑kind distribution to John’s taxable brokerage account and reporting the cost basis as ordinary income on Form 1099‑R for the distribution year.
  4. Complete Roth conversions. Between 2026 and 2028 John converted $50,000 per year from the traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, carefully projecting marginal tax brackets each year and staying below thresholds that would trigger higher surtaxes or Medicare IRMAA increases.
  5. Sell stock on a staged schedule. He sold $150,000 of employer stock in year two (2027) after meeting the one‑year holding period for long‑term capital gains on NUA shares, and planned further sales calibrated to his tax brackets over the next five years.

Results after five years (quantified)

  • Immediate ordinary‑income recognition limited to basis: $60,000 recognized as ordinary income in 2026 (taxed at his marginal rate for that year rather than on the full $600,000).
  • Capital gains treatment on appreciation: When John sold $150,000 of the stock in 2027 he paid long‑term capital gains tax on $135,000 (the NUA portion of those shares), not ordinary income on the full sale amount — converting what otherwise could have been ordinary income into LTCG.
  • Smaller RMD base: Rolling only $330,000 into the IRA and converting $150,000 to Roth over three years reduced the traditional IRA balance subject to RMDs at age 73, lowering projected forced taxable withdrawals and marginal tax pressure in his later 70s.
  • Increased guaranteed income: Delaying Social Security to age 70 increased John’s benefit by roughly 24% compared with claiming at full retirement age (the exact uplift depends on PIA), improving his protected income floor and providing cover for conversion planning.
  • Legacy outcomes: The Roth IRA created by conversions provides heirs tax‑free withdrawals; remaining taxable employer shares retained the NUA tax treatment for gains and could receive a step‑up in basis for any unrealized shares still held at death under current estate tax rules.

Updated considerations for November 2026

Since the original plan, several practical developments and planning realities matter for readers today:

  • RMD timing remains critical. Under SECURE 2.0 the RMD age is 73 for most retirees in 2026 (and rises toward 75 for those born in 1960 or later in later years). That scheduled increase buys time for conversions for many but does not eliminate the need to act before mandatory withdrawals begin.
  • State tax regimes shape the payoff. Some states (for example, California) tax capital gains as ordinary income; in those states NUA’s federal LTCG advantage can be materially reduced. Always model federal and state outcomes together.
  • Plan features vary and are changing. More employers now offer brokerage windows or in‑plan diversification tools, but plan availability and specific language about lump‑sum elections and NUA vary. Confirm in writing with the plan administrator and recordkeepers before making elections.
  • Medicare and other thresholds matter. Roth conversions and one‑time ordinary income recognition can affect Medicare Part B/D premiums (IRMAA) and taxation of Social Security benefits. Model those interactions in the conversion years.
  • Concentration risk and volatility remain real. Post‑2020 market experience reinforced the risk of holding concentrated employer stock in a taxable account. Stagger sales, use limit orders, and consider hedging or charitable techniques for large positions.

Key trade‑offs and constraints

  • NUA requires an eligible lump‑sum distribution after separation from service and plan compliance. Not every participant or plan qualifies.
  • Ordinary‑income tax on the stock’s basis is due in the distribution year — plan liquidity to pay that tax is essential.
  • Lump‑sum distributions can affect plan protections (creditor, spousal consent rules) and foreclose future plan options.
  • State tax treatment, Medicare IRMAA thresholds, and the impact on tax credits or surtaxes can offset some federal benefits.

Lessons learned

  1. Inventory and confirm plan language early. Before electing NUA, get the plan’s written confirmation that a lump‑sum with NUA is allowed and verify spousal consent and reporting mechanics.
  2. Model federal and state outcomes together. Run scenarios that include Medicare IRMAA, taxation of Social Security, and state income tax rates to see the true after‑tax benefit.
  3. Use staged Roth conversions to shrink RMD exposure. Converting in low‑income years reduces the IRA base subject to future RMDs and can be coordinated with delayed Social Security to create conversion windows.
  4. Plan liquidity before distribution. Have cash or low‑taxable assets ready to pay the ordinary tax on the cost basis so you aren’t forced to sell appreciated shares at inopportune times.
  5. Manage concentration risk. Sell employer stock on a schedule that balances tax brackets and portfolio diversification — consider charitable remainder trusts or donor‑advised funds for large, appreciated blocks.

Takeaways

  • NUA can convert large ordinary‑income events into long‑term capital gains on appreciation — potentially a sizable federal tax savings.
  • Eligibility and plan specifics matter: confirm lump‑sum rules, spousal consent, and reporting with the plan administrator before acting.
  • Coordinate NUA with IRA rollovers, Roth conversions and Social Security timing to minimize RMDs and preserve after‑tax cash flow.
  • Model state taxes and Medicare impacts — the federal benefit can be eroded by state tax treatment or IRMAA surcharges.
  • NUA is a specialized tool — it can be powerful when used selectively but is not universally optimal.

When NUA is not optimal

NUA is a poor fit when the stock’s basis is close to market value, when state taxation eliminates the LTCG advantage, when the participant lacks separation‑of‑service eligibility, or when plan protections and spousal issues make staying in the plan preferable. Younger participants or those who cannot pay the basis’s ordinary tax upfront should consider alternatives.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly triggers NUA eligibility?

NUA applies when an employer security is distributed as part of an eligible lump‑sum distribution following separation from service (or death/ disability in some cases) and the participant elects to take the company securities out of the plan. The plan’s SPD and administrator must permit the transaction — get written confirmation and a full understanding of reporting on Form 1099‑R.

How does state tax change the math?

Some states tax capital gains as ordinary income (e.g., California), which reduces or eliminates the federal LTCG advantage of NUA. Always run combined federal‑state models before electing NUA to see the true after‑tax benefit.

Won’t heirs get a step‑up in basis on unsold NUA shares?

Yes. If appreciated employer shares are still held at death, beneficiaries typically receive a step‑up in basis to fair market value on the date of death (or alternate valuation date), eliminating the built‑in capital gain for those shares. That can change whether it makes sense to sell shares during the owner’s lifetime.

Does NUA affect Medicare premiums (IRMAA)?

Potentially. Ordinary income recognized in the distribution year (the stock basis) and Roth conversion income can increase modified adjusted gross income and therefore affect IRMAA surcharges for Medicare Part B and D. Include IRMAA in year‑by‑year modeling.

Should everyone with appreciated company stock use NUA?

No. NUA is a specialized tool that can be highly beneficial in the right circumstances — large appreciation, favorable state tax treatment, ability to pay the ordinary tax on basis, and a plan that permits a lump‑sum. Evaluate alternatives (in‑plan diversification, partial rollovers, charitable strategies, Roth conversions) before deciding.

NUA remains a powerful, underused tax planning lever for retirees with large employer‑stock positions. In November 2026 the core mechanics are unchanged, but the decision now sits inside a broader landscape — RMD‑age changes from SECURE 2.0, state tax regimes, Medicare thresholds, and widespread plan feature variability. For readers holding concentrated employer stock, the immediate practical step is simple: don’t assume eligibility — get the plan documents and run a combined federal‑state‑Medicare model before making the election.